rate: a desk row offers only the buttons that start from its state

The first desk score offered every button of the bucket, where portal
shows a row only the moves from its own state; that scored the live
vel 17 of 26 and sent a rewrite of the neighbour-help desk chasing an
instrument fault. With the row's buttons only: 24 of 26, and the
rewrite loses on the fair test too. Noted: an accent-stripped state id
(ikke_lost) reads as English even to a strong picker.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>

README.md

@@ -328,13 +328,16 @@ its `asked` and `next` columns are the old, pinned ones.
 which reads button labels and nothing else: for every desk and bucket
 with two or more buttons, a worker is told what has just happened to
 a case (in the state's own words, never the label's) and picks the
-button among that desk's, in a rotated order. Scored per desk as
+button among the ones a row in that state shows, in a rotated order.
-right of total, with what each miss was mistaken for. Measured on
+Scored per desk as right of total, with what each miss was mistaken
-2026-09-24: the vel's neighbour-help desk 2 of 4 ("not solved" taken
+for. Measured on 2026-09-24 on the live vel: 24 of 26, the misses
-for "connect a neighbour"), the notice board 1 of 2, the planned
+one button each on the neighbour-help desk and the notice board. Two
-contractor's subcontractor desk 4 of 7 (checking, approved and
+limits: the outcome is put from the state id, and a Norwegian id with
-rejected all crossed). A desk that scores full marks has labels a
+its accents stripped (`ikke_lost`) reads as English even to a strong
-stranger to the business could press right.
+model; and a first version that offered every button of the bucket,
+not the row's, scored the same desks 17 of 26 and sent a rewrite
+chasing an instrument fault. A desk that scores full marks has labels
+a stranger to the business could press right.
 ## Measured so far
 
 **Generated: a building contractor** (`runs/contractor-2026-09-21/`),

runs/tomtervel-opener-2026-09-23/README.md

@@ -47,3 +47,14 @@ reads as volunteering. The live doors stay. What survives every round
 is the same four: hearing input read as a report, a committee read as
 a hearing, and volunteering read as neighbour help - which says the
 doors' seams are the plan's, not the words'.
+
+## Round 4: the neighbour-help desk reworded, and rejected
+
+The first desk score said this desk got 2 of 4 buttons right. Sonnet
+reworded its labels (`/tmp` only); the score got worse with both a
+small and a strong picker, and the strong one showed why: told a case
+"has just become ikke lost", it pressed "Meld ordnet" - it read the
+accent-stripped state id as English. The scorer also offered every
+button of the bucket where a row shows only its own state's. With the
+row's buttons only, the live desk scores 3 of 4 and the vel 24 of 26
+over all desks. The labels stay as they were.

src/rate.rs

@@ -307,19 +307,30 @@ pub fn rate(argv: &[String]) -> anyhow::Result<()> {
     if !desks.is_empty() {
         println!("{:<20} {:<24} {:>8}   {}", "desk", "bucket", "buttons", "mistaken for");
         for (page, group, bucket, moves) in &desks {
-            let labels: Vec<&str> = moves.iter().map(|(_, _, l)| l.as_str()).collect();
+            // A desk row shows only the buttons that start from the
+            // row's state, so those are the ones the worker chooses
+            // among; a state with one button has nothing to confuse.
             let mut right = 0;
+            let mut asked = 0;
             let mut mistaken = Vec::new();
             for (i, (from, to, label)) in moves.iter().enumerate() {
+                let labels: Vec<&str> = moves.iter().filter(|(f, _, _)| f == from).map(|(_, _, l)| l.as_str()).collect();
+                if labels.len() < 2 {
+                    continue;
+                }
+                asked += 1;
                 let picked = button_pick(&cmd, group, bucket, from, to, &labels, i)?;
                 if picked == *label {
                     right += 1;
                 } else {
-                    mistaken.push(format!("{to} as {picked:?}"));
+                    mistaken.push(format!("{from}>{to} as {picked:?}"));
                 }
             }
-            println!("{:<20} {:<24} {:>3} of {:<2}   {}", page, bucket, right, moves.len(), mistaken.join("; "));
+            if asked == 0 {
-            report.insert(format!("desk {page} {bucket}"), json!({ "right": right, "of": moves.len(), "mistaken": mistaken }));
+                continue;
+            }
+            println!("{:<20} {:<24} {:>3} of {:<2}   {}", page, bucket, right, asked, mistaken.join("; "));
+            report.insert(format!("desk {page} {bucket}"), json!({ "right": right, "of": asked, "mistaken": mistaken }));
         }
         println!();
     }